Lies in the Dust review by king-persassy
Lies in the Dust: A Tale of Remorse from the Salem Witch Trials
Age Range - 12 and up
Genre - Historical Fiction

LitPick Review

Profile Picture
Age at time of review - 12
Reviewer's Location - New Fairfield, Connecticut, United States
View king-persassy's profile

Lies in the Dust is a short graphic novel by Jakob Crane and Timothy Decker which tells the tale of the Salem Witch Trials, but with a new twist that few have attempted before. Its pages chronicle these dark days, in which many innocent people were accused of witchcraft and sentenced to death. The accusers, a group of young girls, were faced with barely any punishment for killing. Unlike other books that are centered on the events of Salem, Lies in the Dust doesn’t portray the accusers as merciless killers. It tells the story of Ann Putnam, the only person who apologized for her role in the trial. This creates an emotional new take on the Witch Trials. There is an extreme lack of books on the Salem Witch Trials for younger readers, and Crane’s wonderful novel fills the gap for those who are not quite ready for more mature themed books.

Opinion: 

The great parts of this book make up the majority, and Lies in the Dust truly is stunning when looked at critically. The quiet, slow pace of the book creates a striking contrast with its stark, black and white art. It wastes no time dallying on topics which are unneeded, and each chapter has an impact on the reader which, in my experience, has not been paralleled by many works of literature. Putnam's thoughts on the cruelty of these trials are as beautiful and depressing as they had to be. The majority of the book is thought provoking and intriguing. Though the simple art may sometimes be lacking, it still serves its purpose well. It is simple to imagine the characters any way you wish to, which is an important, easy way to help the reader envision their book. Ann's siblings also represent the innocence which is held by children, even in such a horrible, cruel situation. Once more, its contrast with Ann's older wisdom, gained by all her experience, is an amazing, powerful complement to the book. Its simplistic art style only deepens the impact of its meaning. There is no distraction here, whether with narrative or art, which is why I believe it is a great read for anyone. If you are interested in history, as I am, then I believe you will enjoy this book very much.

However, the book is nowhere near perfect. The pacing of it is fairly difficult to keep up with, as it frequently shifts from Ann’s perspective, post-trial, to a flashback of the trials. The art, though simple, is not of the greatest quality, and it is sometimes difficult to tell what drawings are supposed to be what. Those are all the really striking problems I could find with it, though, so the good parts of this book truly outweigh the bad.

Though it has its own issues, as all books do, Lies in the Dust truly is a masterpiece. And as a debut title for Crane, there is surely much to expect from him in the future. Some of its themes could be found inappropriate, with death and depression being the main violations. Beyond that, I would recommend it to seventh graders and up. Though there is some Old English which is difficult to read, it is not too hard beyond that. However, it still is a challenge, so the book’s difficulty is nicely balanced. If you would like to read about the Salem Witch Trials, but don’t believe that you are ready to tackle a book like The Crucible, then this is just what you need. I would give this book a 4 out of 5 rating.

Rating:
4
Content Rating:

Content rating - some mature content

Explain your content rating: 

Lies in the Dust, taking place in the Salem Witch Trials, includes death and minor gore. Though the images of the hanged people are not in depth, it is still best to be cautious when reading it.
KEYWORDS

ME, YOU, OR THEM: 

CHARACTERISTICS AND EMOTIONS: 

ACTIVITIES, HOBBIES, PLACES, AND EVENTS: 


Read more reviews by this Litpick Book Reviewer: king-persassy
Recommend this book and review to your friends on Facebook